听来听去的，俺认为斯拉夫民族的歌剧，以本国剧院、演员、乐团、指挥四位一体的版本似乎更好一些，也许其味道更为原汁原味吧。


老柴的几部歌剧，俺最爱听最后写的那出《约兰塔》（下面几个老柴，都是莫大的录音）。

莫大的《伊戈尔王》：

莫大的格林卡：

莫大+伦敦的《鲍里斯·戈东诺夫》：

捷克本土的《水仙女》：

很喜欢斯美塔那的新嫁娘，最爱听下面中间1959年的那版：

俺喜欢的波普，还演了一出精彩的新嫁娘：

关于捷克歌剧再多说一句，J.A. 本达的独幕歌剧《乡村集市》，应该是捷克最早的民族歌剧之一。



J.A. 本达简介：
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jiri_Antonin_Benda


This recording, made in 1968, contains the music (but not the dialogue) for a lovely little Singspiel that was first performed in 1775 at the court of the Duke of Gotha in Thuringia. The work concerns a young couple (Lukas and Barbchen) and the attempts to thwart their marriage by a lieutenant who has designs on the latter. He gets his sergeant-major (Fickfack) to convince Lukas to enlist, thereby freeing up Barbchen for himself. Of course the confusion is ironed out and all ends happily. The music never goes beyond airy and charming, but there are a couple of fine trios and duets in addition to some flavorful, folksy arias.

The best role is that of Barbchen, composed for high coloratura, and Renate Krahmer sings both her energetic and introspective music well, albeit with an overly bright tone. Lukas is tenor Hans-Joachim Rotzsch, and while his vocal production tends to be tight, he’s in tune and fluent, and indeed likeable. Fickfack is bass Günther Leib, though he sounds far lighter than a bass, and he’s convincing. The others are good. Orchestra and chorus are perky, involved, and play and sing well under Hans von Benda. This is a bauble, but it’s interesting to find out what the German equivalent of Cimarosa was doing at the time. You’ll know if this is your cup of tea. Sonics are fine.

以上转自：
http://www.classicstoday.com/review/review-9448/

yah 发表于 2017-5-25 20:45
听来听去的，俺认为斯拉夫民族的歌剧，以本国剧院、演员、乐团、指挥四位一体的版本似乎更好一些，也许其味 ...

完全同意亚河兄的说法。莫大和马林斯基哪个更好？我偏爱莫大。另外，一直不明白莫斯科大剧院的英文名字为什么是Bolshoi？

babebr 发表于 2017-5-28 22:04
完全同意亚河兄的说法。莫大和马林斯基哪个更好？我偏爱莫大。另外，一直不明白莫斯科大剧院的英文名字为 ...

俺认为，无论歌剧、还是芭蕾，莫大肯定位列第一。

Bolshoi，不知是不是俄语 Большо́й 的英文音译？
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bolshoi_Theatre

捷克的Supraphon唱片也是名唱片公司，其录音效果一点都不比欧美大牌差。这家公司出版的库贝利克的那张1990年布拉格之春指挥斯美塔那《我的祖国》的现场实况，让多少人趋之若鹜。