很遗憾，我从来都没喜欢过斯瓦兹科普夫，不过，她与塞尔的这版《The Last Four Song》公平地讲还是能如我 ...
狗儿念经 发表于 2011-9-26 01:44

斯瓦兹科普夫的粉丝绝对失望了，包括本菜鸟。
斯瓦虽然被人诟病说缺乏投入涂有机心，但我还是觉得斯瓦的演唱是演唱技巧的完美示范。

不过大家也别过分忽视了杨诺维兹，那是一个百转千回绕指柔的经典版本，杨诺维兹的抒情女高音 演唱及其细腻婉 ...
Roseknight_gao 发表于 2011-9-26 00:19

雅诺维茨的版本当然是我很喜欢的版本！

斯瓦兹科普夫的粉丝绝对失望了，包括本菜鸟。
斯瓦虽然被人诟病说缺乏投入涂有机心，但我还是觉得斯瓦 ...
alma 发表于 2011-9-26 01:48

哈哈，我不喜欢一点不影响老李喜欢嘛，我的好兄弟“帕蒂的玫瑰”就对俺弃斯瓦而倾向诺曼很不了然。

哈哈，我不喜欢一点不影响老李喜欢嘛，我的好兄弟“帕蒂的玫瑰”就对俺弃斯瓦而倾向诺曼很不了然。

...
狗儿念经 发表于 2011-9-26 01:54

请看勃总的最后四首歌帖子，其中有我对雅诺维兹的评价。但我对施瓦兹科普夫已经重新评价了。
http://jd-bbs.com/thread-1956771-1-1.html

各位兄弟版本多啊，我记得我好像只有3个版本，汗啊。
雅诺维兹的LP版，施瓦茨和Popp的CD版，
我比较喜欢施瓦茨的，感觉她的声音很美，
大家都说雅诺维兹好，我不太觉得，可能我那张LP使用过度了。
Popp的版本感觉不佳，不好听。大家别砸我哈。

各位兄弟版本多啊，我记得我好像只有3个版本，汗啊。
雅诺维兹的LP版，施瓦茨和Popp的CD版，
我比较喜欢 ...
shinelb 发表于 2011-9-26 10:34

快买张杨诺维兹的CD吧：）

快买张杨诺维兹的CD吧：）
Roseknight_gao 发表于 2011-9-26 11:36

随缘吧。不必强求。

菜鸟也学习一下。立体声论坛关于最后四首歌的评论：
http://lts.bbs.net/bbs/01/23460.html?soul=1&tz=9.0

我当时的看法是：
“

曾有机会在朋友家里，听了诺曼、施瓦茨科普夫和亚诺薇姿的三个最后四首歌版本。当时scfan大侠也在一起。我当时的看法就是：唱的最好的解析诺曼，这种壮美绝无仅有的，特别是在高音部同时具有穿透性和丰满度，功力非凡。只是她唱的变化比较少，所以显得有点粗。施瓦茨科普夫唱的变化多端，音色多样，但是明显声底差了点，可能真是老了。亚诺薇姿其实唱的变化也很少，但是她声音的特点非常适合于这个曲子，显得很高贵很有境界，所以亚诺薇姿版我最喜欢。

”

我现在还是认为，雅诺维兹版，位于我最喜欢的第二位。

雅诺维茨的版本当然是我很喜欢的版本！
狗儿念经 发表于 2011-9-26 01:50

你我都没有提到雅诺维兹版本好在哪里啊？
念大师谈谈。

Four Last Songs discography

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Chronological - by no means complete - list of recordings of Richard Strauss' Vier letzte Lieder.

[edit]

Recordings

Year	Artist	Conductor Orchestra or Pianist	Label Catalogue number
1950	Kirsten Flagstad	Wilhelm Furtwängler Philharmonia Orchestra	Audio CD: Testament Cat: SBT1410[1]
1951	Sena Jurinac	Fritz Busch Stockholm Philharmonic Orchestra	Audio CD: EMI "Références" Cat: CDH 7 63199 2[2]
1953	Elisabeth Schwarzkopf	Otto Ackermann Philharmonia Orchestra	Audio CD: Naxos "Historical" Cat: 8.111145[3]
1953	Lisa della Casa	Karl Böhm Wiener Philharmoniker	Audio CD: Decca "Legends" Cat: 000289 467 1182 8[4] Audio CD: Naxos "Historical" Cat: 8.111347[5]
1955	Christel Goltz	Heinrich Hollreiser Pro Musica Orchestra	Audio LP: VOX Classics Cat: PL 9400
1956	Elisabeth Schwarzkopf	Herbert von Karajan Philharmonia Orchestra	Audio CD: Urania Cat: URN 22. 379
1958	Inge Borkh	Ferdinand Leitner Orchestre Symphonique de Vichy	Audio CD: Ponto Recordings Cat: PONTO 1010[6]
1958	Lois Marshall	Thomas Beecham Concertgebouworkest	Audio CD: Gala Cat: GL 100.799
1961	Sena Jurinac	Malcolm Sargent BBC Symphony Orchestra	Audio CD: BBC "Legends" Cat: BBCL 4107-2[7]
1961	Teresa Stich-Randall	Ernest Ansermet Orchestre de la Suisse Romande	Audio CD: Cascavalle: VEL 3135
1964	Elisabeth Schwarzkopf	George Szell Concertgebouworkest	Audio CD: Audiophile Classics Cat: APL 101.548
1964	Evelyn Lear	Karl Böhm Wiener Philharmoniker	Audio CD: VAI Music Cat: VAIA 1159[8]
1964	Hanne-Lore Kuhse	Václav Neumann Gewandhausorchester Leipzig	Audio CD: Berlin Classics Cat: BC 2075-2
1965	Elisabeth Schwarzkopf	George Szell Radio-Symphonieorchester Berlin	Audio CD: EMI Classics "Great Recordings of the Century" Cat: 0724356696020[9]
1967	Martina Arroyo	Günter Wand Kölner Rundfunk-Sinfonie-Orchester	Audio CD: Profil Cat: PH06005[10]
1968	Gundula Janowitz	Bernard Haitink Concertgebouworkest (concert recording)	Audio CD: Philips "Dutch Masters - Bernard Haitink Vol. 48" Cat: 462 947-2
1970	Birgit Nilsson	Leif Segerstam Sveriges Radios symfoniorkester	Audio CD: Bluebell Cat: ABCD 009
1970	Eleanor Steber	James Levine Cleveland Orchestra	Audio CD: VAI Music Cat: VAIA 1012[11]
1974	Leontyne Price	Erich Leinsdorf New Philharmonia Orchestra	Audio CD: RCA Victor Cat: nla[12]
1974	Gundula Janowitz	Herbert von Karajan Berliner Philharmoniker	Audio CD: Deutsche Grammophon "The Originals" Cat: 000289 447 4222 0[13]
1976	Elisabeth Söderström	Antal Dorati Royal Philharmonic Orchestra	Audio CD: BBC "Legends" Cat: BBCL 4153-2[14]
1976	Montserrat Caballé	Alain Lombard Orchestre Philharmonique de Strasbourg	Audio LP: Erato Cat: STU 71054
1976	Teresa Żylis Gara	Franz-Paul Decker Rundfunk-Sinfonieorchester Hannover	Audio LP: Rodolphe Cat: RP 12 392
1977	Aase Nordmo Løvberg	Okko Kamu Oslo Philharmonic Orchestra	Audio CD: Simax Cat: PSC 1803
1977	Lucia Popp	Georg Solti Chicago Symphony Orchestra	DVD-Video: Decca Cat: 074 3203[15]
1979	Kiri Te Kanawa	Andrew Davis London Symphony Orchestra	Audio CD: Sony Classical Cat: SMK89881[16]
1981	Sylvia Sass	Ervin Lukács Hungarian State Orchestra	Audio LP: Hungaroton Cat: SLPX 12397[17]
1981	Heather Harper	Norman Del Mar Royal Philharmonic Orchestra	Audio CD: Carlton Classics Cat: 15656 91382
1982	Roberta Alexander	Adam Gatehouse National Youth Orchestra of the Netherlands	Audio LP: Eurosound Cat: ES 46.583[18]
1982	Elisabeth Söderström	Richard Armstrong Welsh National Opera Orchestra	Audio LP: EMI Cat: ASD 4103
1982	Lucia Popp	Klaus Tennstedt London Philharmonic Orchestra	Audio CD: EMI Classics Cat: 0724358643725[19]
1982	Jessye Norman	Kurt Masur Gewandhausorchester Leipzig	Audio CD: Philips Classics Cat: 000289 464 7422 8[20]
1983	Elly Ameling	Wolfgang Sawallisch Concertgebouworkest	Audio CD: Heartselling Cat: GW 80003
1985	Anna Tomowa-Sintow	Herbert von Karajan Berliner Philharmoniker	Audio CD: Deutsche Grammophon Cat: 419 188-2[21]
1985	éva Marton	Andrew Davis Toronto Symphony Orchestra	Audio LP: CBS Cat: IM 42019
1986	Felicity Lott	Neeme Järvi Royal Scottish National Orchestra	Audio CD: Chandos Cat: CHAN 8518[22]
1987	Heather Harper	Richard Hickox London Symphony Orchestra	Audio CD: EMI Classics Cat: 2283742[23]
1988	Arleen Augér	André Previn Wiener Philharmoniker	Audio CD: Telarc Cat: CD-80180[24]
1990	Kiri Te Kanawa	Georg Solti Wiener Philharmoniker	Audio CD: Decca Cat: 000289 430 5112 5[25]
1991	Gwyneth Jones	Roberto Paternostro Tokyo Symphony Orchestra	Audio CD: KOCH Schwann Cat: 314 081
1992	Julia Varady	Kurt Masur Gewandhausorchester Leipzig	DVD-Video: Digital Classics Cat: 1008DC
1993	Cheryl Studer	Giuseppe Sinopoli Staatskapelle Dresden	Audio CD: Deutsche Grammophon Cat: 000289 439 8652 6[26]
1993	Elisabeth Meyer-Topsøe	Hans Norbert Bihlmaier Sjællands Symfoniorkester	Audio CD: Kontrapunkt Cat: 32156[27]
1993	Charlotte Margiono	Edo de Waart Radio Filharmonisch Orkest Holland	Audio CD: Brilliant Classics Cat: 9065[28]
1993	Lucia Popp	Michael Tilson Thomas London Symphony Orchestra	Audio CD: Sony Classical Cat: SK 48242[29]
1995	Barbara Hendricks	Wolfgang Sawallisch Philadelphia Orchestra	Audio CD: EMI Classics Cat: CDC5 5099950466528[30]
1995	Renée Fleming	Christoph Eschenbach Houston Symphony Orchestra	Audio CD: RCA Cat: 09026 68539 2[31]
1995	Carole Farley	José Serebrier Czech State Philharmonic Orchestra	Audio CD: Classic FM Cat: 756055700227[32]
1995	Joanna Borowska	Friedrich Haider Cracow Radio Symphony Orchestra	Audio CD: Nightingale Classics Cat: NC161864-2[33]
1996	Hellen Kwon	Adrian Leaper Orquesta Filarmónica de Gran Canaria	Audio CD: Arte Nova Cat: 74321 54466 2[34]
1998	Barbara Bonney	Malcolm Martineau, piano	Audio CD: Decca Cat: 460 812-2[35]
1998	Deborah Voigt	Kurt Masur New York Philharmonic Orchestra	Audio CD: Teldec Cat: 3984-25990-2[36]
1998	Karita Mattila	Claudio Abbado Berliner Philharmoniker	Audio CD: Deutsche Grammophon Cat: 445 182-2[37]
1999	Gabriele Fontana	Erik Werba, piano	Audio CD: Preiser Records Cat: PR93377[38]
1999	Jane Eaglen	Donald Runnicles London Symphony Orchestra	Audio CD: Sony Cat: SK 61720[39]
1999	Karita Mattila	Claudio Abbado Berliner Philharmoniker	Audio CD: Deutsche Grammophon Cat: 000289 445 1822 1[40]
1999	Gitta-Maria Sjöberg	Jan Wagner Odense Symfoniorkester	DVD-Audio: Silverline Cat: 288119-9[41]
2001	Soile Isokoski	Marek Janowski Rundfunk-Sinfonieorchester Berlin	Audio CD: Ondine Cat: ODE982-2[42]
2002	Melanie Diener	David Zinman Tonhalle Orchester Zürich	Audio CD: Arte Nova Cat: 74321 95999 2[43]
2003	Georgina von Benza	Marco De Prosperis Rundfunk-Sinfonieorchester Saarbrücken	Audio CD: TADE International Cat: TADECD 002[44]
2004	Anne Schwanewilms	Mark Elder The Hallé	Audio CD: BBC Cat: BBC MM270[45]
2004	Michaela Kaune	Eiji Oue NDR Radiophilharmonie	Audio CD: Berlin Classics Cat: 0017812BC[46]
2004	Nancy Yuen	Somtow Sucharitkul Siam Philharmonc Orchestra	Audio CD: Orchid Music Cat: OM-0401[47]
2005	Konrad Jarnot	Helmut Deutsch, piano	Audio CD: Oehms Classics Cat: OC 518[48]
2006	Christine Brewer	Donald Runnicles Atlanta Symphony Orchestra	Audio CD: Telarc Cat: CD-80661[49]
2006	Ricarda Merbeth	Michael Halász Staatskapelle Weimar	Audio CD: Naxos Cat: 8.570283[50]
2006	Nina Stemme	Antonio Pappano Orchestra of the Royal Opera House, London	Audio CD: EMI Classics Cat: 0094637879726[51]
2006	Ricarda Merbeth	Gianluigi Gelmetti Sydney Symphony Orchestra	Audio CD: Sydney Symphony Recordings Cat: SSO 200803[52]
2007	Qilian Chen	Dirk Brossé Shanghai Opera House Orchestra	Audio CD: Pavane Records Cat: ADW 7542[53]
2007	Anja Harteros	Fabio Luisi Sächsische Staatskapelle Dresden	Audio CD: Sony Classical Cat: 88697 14197-2[54]
2007	Barbara Krieger	Heiko Mathias Förster Berliner Symphoniker	Audio CD: Brilliant Classics Cat: 8957[55]
2007	Waltraud Meier	Joseph Breinl, piano	Audio CD: Farao Classics Cat: B 108033[56]
2008	Yvonne Kenny	Johannes Fritzsch Queensland Symphony Orchestra	Audio CD: ABC Classics Cat: ABC 476 3954[57]
2009	Renée Fleming	Christian Thielemann Münchner Philharmoniker	Audio CD: Decca Cat: 000289 478 1074 2[58]
2009	Anja Harteros	Mariss Jansons Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks	Audio CD: BR-Klassik Cat: 900707[59]
2009	Aga Mikolaj	Karl Sollak WDR Rundfunfunkorchester Köln	Audio CD: CPO Cat: 777 641-2[60]
2010	Polina Pasztircsák	Alexander Rahbari Musikkollegium Winterthur	Audio CD: Nascor Cat: NS07[61]
2010	Dorothea Röschmann	Yannick Nézet-Séguin Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra	Audio CD: BIS Records Cat: BIS-SACD-1880[62]

[edit]